|
Ruger SR1911 Review In the other parts of my Ruger SR1911 Pistol Review, I cover What's In The Box, External & Operational Features, and Disassembly with lots of photos and commentary. In this part of the review, I cover the internal features and components of the Ruger SR1911 Pistol. Throughout this review you can click on any photo to bring up a high resolution photo allowing you to see the details in the photos. Although I have not commented on every photo, I have tried to provide views of all the features so you can form your own opinion on the components and features of the SR1911 pistol. Not that it really matters, I have listed these parts in the basic order of reassembly which may help those less familiar with 1911 pistols.
Frame The frame is a stainless steel investment casting that is made from Ruger's proprietary blend of metal that is somewhere between 410 and 420 stainless steel and the frame is then machined to it's final dimensions. Ruger rounded all sharp edges and did a good job with the evenness of the stainless matte bead blast finish. The plunger tube is integrally molded into the frame. The Vertical Impact Surface (VIS) has a bowtie cut and it appears, by looking at the barrel lugs, that the barrel lugs are striking the surface properly. Trigger Assembly The trigger assembly is actually made up of three parts; the aluminum skeletonized trigger, steel trigger bow and over travel stop set screw. The over travel stop set screw appears to have some type of red thread locking compound to prevent the screw from working loose.
Figure 18 Magazine Catch Assembly The magazine catch assembly is made from steel. Disconnector The disconnector appears to be a stainless steel MIM (Metal Injection Molded) part. Sear Manufactured using the MIM process.
Figure 26
Figure 27
Figure 28
Figure 29 Sear Pin Hammer & Strut The hammer is a MIM part made from stainless steel with the sides of the hammer milled off to give the bright stainless finish. The strut appears to be a stamped steel part.
Figure 31
Figure 32
Figure 33
Figure 34 Hammer Pin Sear Spring Mainspring Housing & Pin The mainspring housing is a MIM part. I didn't disassemble the housing to examine the internal components.
Figure 41
Figure 42
Figure 43
Figure 44 Grip Safety Manufactured using the MIM process. Safety Lock Manufactured using the MIM process. Grips The grips on the SR191 are Rosewood panels with a plastic Ruger logo inlay that is held in place with a short stud that is expanded on the opposite side of the wooden grips. Slide & Sights The slide is machined from 416 stainless steel bar stock and the sights are MIM parts. Although the sights are made by Novak, I believe they are made to Ruger's specifications. Firing Pin Spring Ruger states the firing pin spring to be a "heavy spring" to assist with passing a drop test. Firing Pin The titanium firing pin has an undercut area on the rear end to assist with the weight reduction of the pin which is a key requirement to pass a drop test. Extractor Firing Pin Stop Barrel & Link The broached barrel is made from 410 stainless steel. The photo below shows the proof mark on the left side of the barrel lug. Using the pictures above and below, notice that the barrel appears to be properly throated with a mirror like finish. Also in the photo below on the left, you can see where the barrel lugs are making contact with the vertical impact surface (VIS) by the bowtie marks appearing on the top of the lugs. Recoil Spring Guide The recoil spring guide rod is a one-piece short solid rod made from stainless steel. Recoil Spring The recoil spring is a 18.5 pound spring weight. Recoil Spring Plug Barrel Bushing One thing that is unique about the barrel bushing is that it is machined at the same time out of the same bar stock as the barrel which is 410 stainless steel . I can see there may be an advantage to this method. While the stock material is mounted in the machine for the turning operations, they are able to turn the bushing surfaces (both inside and outside diameters) to be concentric with the outside of the barrel which in turn may allow them to hold overall tighter tolerances on the fit of these parts. Ruger then keeps the barrel and bushing together as a matched pair throughout the remainder of the pistol build. The clearance between the barrel bushing and slide measured 0.0055" and between the bushing and barrel measured 0.0035". Slide Stop Manufactured using the MIM process. The pin diameter measured 0.1965" which appears to be less than the standard 0.1985" to 2.0005". Another feature I found interesting was the flat portion on the bottom of the pin. Maybe I don't know enough about 1911's, but I don't believe it was intended by John Browning based on his drawings. Since a similar flat existed on the safety lock pin, the flats must be related to the MIM process or Ruger has something else in mind. Also notice the wear in the left photo in the area of the barrel link. The barrel link is riding the slide stop pin during lockup. I confirmed this by installing the pin hanging down and then testing the amount of force to rotate the pin when in lockup. The pin was not loose.
Thoughts Actually several thoughts come to mind. The first is it appears that the Ruger SR1911 pistol is a quality made pistol. The only blemishes are those on the MIM parts which is related to the gate location on the mold and how they separate the parts after molding. I didn't measure every dimension, but overall the quality seems good for the price. My range tests show that the accuracy you can get out of this pistol is more than enough needed for self defense and probably more than your average shooter can fully utilize. There are some components that could potentially be swapped (i.e. the slide stop, barrel link and barrel bushing) to tighten up the pistol and convert it in the direction of a custom/match pistol. My next thought has to do with the use of MIM (Metal Injection Molding) parts. Ruger has used several MIM parts and honestly I'm glad to see this trend. When you look at a comparison of MIM versus Machining versus Casting for properly manufactured parts (see this link) , MIM parts have a clear advantage and it takes companies like Ruger who are willing to take the risks and invest in their process to bring quality as well as value to the consumer (us). Will there be lessons learned along the way? Sure, but at least a company like Ruger will make things right when some type of issue comes up. My last thought is that I'm sure my wife thinks I'm totally nuts for spending all the time it takes to put together a detailed review. She is probably right, but I still like doing it. For more detailed photos and commentary, make sure you check out the other parts of this review and feel free to leave comments on my Reader's Comments page. The following links are provided to help you see other parts of this review.
Or If you would like to be notified about future Gunsumer Reports reviews via Facebook, make sure "You Like This" by clicking the Facebook "Like" button at the bottom or top of this page. If it already says "You Like This" beside the button, clicking it again will uncheck the "Like" status and you will not be notified.
|
||||
© 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 & 2024 Gunsumer Reports™, All rights reserved. FTC Disclosure |